This is probably the section you’ve been looking forward to the most and, honestly, it’s one of the most important parts of a successful influencer marketing campaign. Experience tells us that when these campaigns don’t go well, often it’s because of the strategy, not the influencer. Please don’t hate us for saying that.
You need to put in the hard yards at this stage, more than any other, to choose the right people. It’s going to take a lot of research, looking through data, and scrolling through your socials. It also means building relationships with influencers who do well, so you know you can go back to them.
There are a number of tools you can use to help you through the process of finding new influencers to work with. Upfluence and Ninjalitics both offer free versions for a limited number of searches, otherwise, you can pay for their premium features. It can get pricey, so we recommend trying to work through the process manually at first so you can get a feel for the ins and outs of it.
What should you look for in an influencer?
There are several key things to look at when choosing influencers (aside from the fact that they need to live in the areas you’re targeting):
Engagement
This is a buzzword when it comes to influencer marketing, but for a good reason. Originally, all brands looked for were influencers who had a lot of followers and looked pretty. In reality, this doesn’t really work for anyone and while you can certainly get a lot of reach, that’s rarely going to help you achieve tangible marketing goals.
There are different forms of engagement and when you look across multiple platforms, you’ll see that some of them offer more importance than others. For instance, on Twitter re-Tweets are really important and on Instagram saves are really important. One thing all platforms agree on though, is comments. Comments are where you can gather incredibly valuable information about audience sentiment and where you can engage in meaningful conversations.
Engagement rate
An influencer’s engagement rate is a good indicator of how highly their audience regards their content. Using publicly available information, you can calculate the engagement rate using this formula:
Eng. rate = avg. number of engagements / followers
Where the average number of engagements comes from their last few posts.
For nano influencers on Instagram, aim for an engagement rate of at least 5% but as their audience grows, this can go down to a minimum of 2.5%. *Note: the environment has changed over the past year or so and average engagement rates are declining. For larger influencers, you may wish to aim for a minimum of 1%.
Matching voice
We’ve said it before and we’ll say it again. The best content is authentic content. Your influencer knows how to create content their audience will enjoy and, conversely, your audience knows when you’ve created the content for your influencer.
Choose influencers who already align with your brand voice and image, so you don’t feel the need to restrict their creativity too much. This is in relation to their style of imagery, the filters they use, and how they speak in their captions and stories.
Audience
As with any marketing campaign, you want to be sure you’re targeting the right audience. With influencers, this comes in the form of their followers (largely, obviously other people can still view their content too).
The platforms mentioned earlier will show you audience data as part of their paid subscriptions. This includes information about where their followers live (down to the city in some instances), their gender split, and what topics their followers are interested in.
But, once you’ve got a shortlist of influencers you’d like to work with, you can ask for this information yourself. In the early stages of your outreach to them, make sure it’s clear that while you’d like to work with them, it’s dependent on them having an audience that matches your desired target.
#TooManySponsoredPosts
The whole reason for using influencers is to offer an authentic voice for your brand. Working with someone who promotes products in every other post will likely dampen that authentic message.
Keep in mind though, that influencers in some industries (like beauty and fashion) will tag brands in almost every photo, simply because that’s what their followers want to know. They’re not necessarily being asked to promote those brands.